A fishing boat moored to a timber dock on Lake Pend Oreille beneath misty evergreen hills in late-November morning light.

Bayview's Thanksgiving Derby Week on Lake Pend Oreille

Last November, two anglers each weighed a 23.95-pound rainbow in the Lake Pend Oreille Idaho Club's fall derby. Tim Smith won the adult rainbow division with his 38½-inch fish. Craig O'Neal finished second with a fish of the same weight because his was caught later, as the Bonner County Daily Bee reported. The club's rules decide every tie that way, with the first fish weighed taking the place.

The 2026 Fall Thanksgiving Derby opens at 6 a.m. this Saturday, November 21. One of its three official weigh stations is at MacDonald's Hudson Bay Resort in Bayview. That same resort also has an Idaho Fish and Game freezer, where anglers turn in lake trout heads for a $15 reward each. During derby week, two separate prize systems meet on one Bayview dock. Between them, they pay anglers to put big rainbows back in the lake and to keep lake trout out of it.

The derby week, day by day

The derby takes Thanksgiving Day off and runs nine days in total, from Saturday to Sunday.

Dates What's happening
Saturday, Nov. 21, through Wednesday, Nov. 25 Fishing opens at 6 a.m. on the 21st. Weigh stations open 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. daily
Thursday, Nov. 26 No fishing on Thanksgiving
Friday, Nov. 27, through Sunday, Nov. 29 Fishing resumes. The derby ends at 4 p.m. on the 29th

Entry is $60 for adults and $10 for juniors ages 13 to 17. Youth anglers 12 and under fish free but must preregister. In Bayview, the fall 2026 ticket outlets are MacDonald's Hudson Bay Resort and Ralph's Coffee House. Tickets are also sold at LPOIC.org, where online sales opened October 21. The other outlets are spread from Hope and Garfield Bay to Hayden, Coeur d'Alene, Ponderay, Oldtown, Priest River and Kootenai. Bayview General Mercantile appears in this fall's newsletter as a sponsor of the Youth and Junior divisions.

The three weigh stations are Holiday Shores in Hope, the public boat ramp in Garfield Bay, and MacDonald's Hudson Bay Resort in Bayview. Fish must come in by boat and be weighed the same day by the angler who caught them. They also have to come from Lake Pend Oreille itself. Fish from the Clark Fork River or any tributary don't count. If anyone on a boat holds a derby ticket, everyone aboard with a current Idaho fishing license has to be registered too, and that includes charter boats.

Two divisions, two very different prize tables

The adult rainbow and adult mackinaw divisions are scored differently, and the gap tells you what the club is rewarding.

Adult Rainbow Division

  • 32-inch minimum length
  • $3,000 for first, $1,500 for second, $1,000 for third, $500 for fourth
  • $500 catch-and-release bonus and a $250 members bonus

Adult Mackinaw Division

  • No minimum length
  • $1,000 for first, $500 for second, $300 for third, $200 for fourth
  • $100 each for fifth through ninth, $250 for tenth
  • $150 Mac of the Day prize

Mackinaw is another name for lake trout. That division has no size floor, pays ten places, and adds a daily prize, so anglers can bring mackinaw in every fishing day of the derby. The rainbow side is the trophy hunt, with a high minimum, four paid places and a bonus for letting the fish go. Rainbows and mackinaw can both be weighed more than once, so an angler can keep bringing in fish and improving their spot in the standings.

The fall purse is smaller than the spring one. At the spring 2026 derby, first place for adult rainbow paid $5,000 and first for adult mackinaw paid $1,200, according to the Coeur d'Alene Press. The fall table above is the one that applies this month.

Juniors have their own division, with a 28-inch rainbow minimum, mackinaw of any size, and prizes from $500 for first down to $200 for fourth. They also get a $100 rainbow catch-and-release bonus. Youth A covers ages 9 to 12 and Youth B covers ages 8 and under. Both have no minimum lengths and award trophies and prizes for first through third. Youth catch-and-release fish are entered by texting a photo along with a copy of the youth's registration.

The freezer next to the scale

The second prize system has nothing to do with the club. Through its Angler Incentive Program, Idaho Fish and Game pays a $15 reward for each Lake Pend Oreille lake trout head turned in at its marked freezers. Lake trout and walleye have no bag limit on the lake. Bayview has two freezer locations:

  1. MacDonald's Hudson Bay Resort, 17813 E Hudson Bay Rd
  2. Bayview Marina Main Office, 18354 Hwy. 54

The steps are simple. Bag the whole head with a data slip from the freezer station, fill out and sign the slip in pencil because ink won't stick to the waterproof paper, and keep lake trout and walleye heads in separate bags. Heads of the same species caught in the same month can share one bag and one slip.

A mackinaw that's weighed in Bayview and kept is still a legally harvested Lake Pend Oreille lake trout, so its head is still eligible for the $15. Rainbows work the other way. The program pays nothing for rainbow heads, and the derby pays a $500 bonus to an adult who places in the rainbow division and releases the fish after weighing. That's what happened at the top of the spring standings. The second-, third- and fourth-place adult rainbows all went back into the lake after weighing.

Why the state pays for lake trout heads

Both systems serve the same fish. In a July 20, 2026 update, Idaho Fish and Game said lake trout and walleye are effective predators that can reduce kokanee populations. The agency also said kokanee support the lake's world-renowned trophy rainbow trout fishery. Every lake trout taken out leaves more kokanee for the rainbows the derby is built around.

The lake trout program started in 2006, and walleye were added in 2019. Idaho Fish and Game says anglers have earned about $1.5 million in lake trout rewards since 2006, including about $32,000 in the year before that July update. The program is funded by the Clark Fork Settlement Agreement through Avista. In the same update, Rob Ryan, a mitigation staff biologist with the agency, said anglers and spearfishers in the program "have played and continue to play an instrumental role in Lake Pend Oreille kokanee recovery."

Walleye are rewarded differently. About 60 walleye in the lake carry tiny tags worth $1,000 each to whoever catches one. Every walleye head turned in also earns an entry into a monthly drawing for ten $100 rewards. To count in a drawing, walleye heads have to be turned in the same month the fish was caught, so a walleye caught over Thanksgiving weekend needs to reach a freezer before December.

A derby that started with a rainbow

The trophy rainbows came first. The Lake Pend Oreille Idaho Club's derbies date to 1947, after Gerrard rainbows from Canada were planted in the lake earlier in the 1940s, the Coeur d'Alene Press reported. Recent results show what the top of the board looks like:

Derby Adult rainbow winner Adult mackinaw winner
Fall 2025 Tim Smith, 23.95 lb, 38½ in. John Powers, 12.55 lb
Spring 2026 Scott Chapple, 24.30 lb, 36 in. Bert Dennett, 20.20 lb, 36¼ in.

Last fall's winning rainbow and last spring's were only a third of a pound apart. With weights that close, Smith's 2025 win came down to the timing rule from the top of this post, so an early weigh-in can matter.

Following along from shore

You can follow the standings without a boat or a ticket. During the derby, reports go out over VHF radio three times a day, and standings changes are posted on LPOIC's Facebook page and at lpoic.org as soon as possible. Other prizes include $100 for the best photo taken during the derby by an entrant, and a $250 Pin Purchaser Bonus for the adult pin purchaser who catches the highest-placing rainbow and mackinaw.

If you keep a boat on the south end, derby week overlaps with putting the lake to bed. Our seasonal dock schedule for Lake Pend Oreille and Bayview winterizing plan cover that side of late November. For the warmer-month calendar, see our guide to a Bayview summer.

The rules above are summarized from the club's published derby rules and Idaho Fish and Game's program page. They're general information, so please check the full LPOIC rules and current Idaho fishing regulations before you head out.

The busiest Thanksgiving week on the south end runs through MacDonald's Hudson Bay Resort, and I love seeing what comes back to that dock. If your family's lake time is part of why Bayview feels like home, Rachael Holzhauser is glad to talk shoreline, moorage and life on the water. Schedule a free consultation whenever it suits you.

Work With Rachael

Ready for a stress-free real estate experience? I offer personalized strategies and global exposure to help you achieve your goals. Let’s get started!

Follow Me on Instagram